Biographies from County Histories and other Sources

 

ASBenedict.jpg (84547 bytes)

AARON  BENEDICT, farmer; P. O. Bennington, is the second son of William Benedict, who came from Peru Tp., Essex Co., New York, and settled in Peru Tp., (then Delaware Co.) in 1812. Aaron was born in the year 1817, and was one of the first persons born in Peru Tp. He has twice been married, his first wife being Caroline Dague, his second, Louisa M. Meeker. The children by the first marriage, are as follows: Adessa, Linton, Margaret Jane, (Wyman deceased), Direxa, Lester P., William, Frederick, and Addison, deceased. By the last marriage there is but one child Preston Benedict. By occupation Mr. Benedict is a farmer, uniting many and varied characteristics. For fifteen years he has applied himself assiduously to the propagation of bees, especially the Italian bee, queens of which variety he has sent to all parts of the Union, and was the first party who was able to send !an Italian queen to the Sandwich Islands alive and in good condition. He has a particular penchant for the breeding and rearing of wild animals and fowls, especially the American wild turkey, and at the date of this writing, there is in his hands an order from California for a pair of these fowls, to be shipped thence. As a woodsman, Aaron has always been considered in the foremost rank, and recognized by his associates as the most expert of hunters, possessing in an eminent degree, even from boyhood, a knowledge of the habits of the game which he sought to capture. He is a member of the Society of Friends, the oldest church organization in the township.

THEODORE K. BENEDICT, farmer; P. O. Bennington. Theodore, as were his ancestors, is a member of the Society of Friends; a man of modern ideas and notions of reform; a farmer by preference, and strongly attached to his business; he is sparing neither pains nor expense in rendering his home pleasant and attractive; he is a cattle dealer and breeder, and enjoys the business more than any other branch of stock raising; he cultivates music in his household, discourses on the questions of public policy, and allows himself a wider range for reflection than has hitherto usually been accorded to, or by, the society of which he is a member. He is a good, reliable, intelligent, and hospitable citizen a business man and useful citizen who lives in the enjoyment of his family. His parents were Ezra Benedict, born in the State of New York, June 21, 1803, and Miss Ruth Gridley, born in Saratoga, Saratoga Co., New York, July 3, 1807, and were married Oct. 4, 1827, in Peru Tp. Theodore was born June 6, 1835, in Lincoln Tp., Morrow Co. His wife, Susan H. King, was born in Franklin Co., Ohio, June 27, 1837, and on the 18th day of November, 1856, they became man and wife. Mrs. Benedict's parents were the Rev. Win. King, and Mary Ann Eastwood, of Columbus, Mr. King being a resident of Franklinton. Theodore's family is as follows: Ruth Millicent, born Aug. 25,1858; George, Dylwin, Aug. 1, 1860, and died Aug. 30, 1865; William H., born March 28, 1863; Mary Lillian, Nov. 2, 1866; Reuben G., Sept. 29, 1870.

JAMES ALANSTON "Lant" BROWNING was born on Feb 5 1862 in Hartford Twp., Licking Co., Ohio. He died on Apr 4 1930 in Fulton, Morrow Co., Ohio. He was buried in Fulton, Morrow Co., Ohio. He was married to Catherine "Kate" CHAMBERS on Aug 21 1883 in Delaware Co., Ohio. 1920 census living on West Main St., Fulton, Morrow Co., Ohio They owned their home with a mortgage. Catherine "Kate" CHAMBERS was born in Jul 1861.

ISADORA "Dora" BROWNING was born on Oct 24 1863 in Hartford Twp., Licking Co., Ohio. She died on Nov 2 1911 in Fulton, Morrow Co., Ohio. She was buried on Nov 5 1911 in Fulton, Morrow Co., Ohio. NEWSPAPER CLIPPING; IZA DORA (ISADORA)(BROWNING) MULVAIN died at the home of her daughter, Mrs. Bert Potts, Thursday, November 2, 1911, at 3 p.m., aged 48 years and 8 days. She was the daughter of H.A. and M.J. Browning, and was born in Licking County, October 24, 1863. She was united in marriage with David O. Mulvain, November 7, 1879, in Richwood, Ohio, where the first ten years of their wedded life were spent. They then moved to Henry County, and later to Fulton, until a little over a year ago she, with her family, moved to South Woodbury where she gained many warm friends. When but a small girl she gave her heart to the Lord and has remained steadfast in her allegiance to the Church. She read her Bible daily and found strength at the throne of grace to bear her suffering which was intense; she never murmured, but trusted in the Allwise God at all times. Sdhe leaves in deep sorrow her husband, three sons, two daughters, three grandchildren, five brothers, two sisters and many near relatives and friends to mourn their loss, but we do not mourn as those who have no hope. She was a devoted wife and mother, always ministering to the wants of others. Funeral services were held Sunday morning, conducted by Rev. Boroff. We have lost our darling mother; She has gone to live in heaven, And her form is lost to view; Oh, That dear one, how we loved her; Oh, how hard to give her up.  

BIOGRAPHIES: some from L.H. Baskins , The History of Morrow & Delaware Counties, Ohio 1880.  

GEORGE N. CLARK, Vice-President of the Morrow County Batik, Mt. Gilead; was born in Boardman Tp., Trumbull, now Mahoning Co., Ohio, March 24, 1814, and like others at that early period, had few facilities for acquiring- art education; he lived at home on the farm until he was 24 years of age, and March 22, 1838, he married Miss Mary A. Lowry; she was born in the same county. After his marriage he moved to Portage Co., where he farmed one year, and in the spring of 1839 he came to Woodbury, Delaware, now Morrow Co., and engaged in the general merchandise business, which he continued there for twenty-six years, serving as Postmaster for twenty-two years of that time; also, in 1851 he was elected on the Democratic ticket the first Representative of this county, to the Ohio Legislature, and served for two terms, it being the first session of the new constitution. July 18, 1862, he was appointed Adjutant of the 96th 0. V. I., and served with that command for eight months, when, owing to disabilities, he received his discharge. In 1864 he came to Mt. Gilead and served as County Auditor for four years, since which time he has been Superintendent of the County Infirmary for three and one-half years, and has also been identified with several of the business interests of this place. July 18, 1876, Mr. Clark was called to mourn the death of his wife; they had five children, of whom four are Living - Cyrus C., Augustine, Alice M. and Samuel C. In Feb. 1880, the Morrow County National Bank was organized, with Mr. Clark as Vice-President, and began business March 22, following. In early times when in business at Woodbury, Mr. Clark had his goods hauled by wagon from Sandusky, and in other ways participated in the comforts of pioneer life.  

IRA & LUCY H. (Humiston) CLAY (by Paul Clay): The first record I've found for Ira Clay is in the 1830 Census for New York State, Madison County in the city of Cazenovia. This shows a migration pattern from the North.  At this time, the census shows, Ira and his wife had two sons, one under the age of five years (Morris),and one of the age of five but not yet ten years of age (Henry D.), living in Cazenovia. Ira was a prominent "Anti-Mason"*. This movement was started in 1826, after William Morgan, a citizen of western New York published a book in which the secrets of freemasonry were supposed to be disclosed. William Morgan was seized on September 11, at Batavia, upon a criminal charge, taken to Canandaigua, tried and acquitted on the criminal charge, but was immediately arrested on a civil process. He was cast into jail and then taken from place to place by members of the masons. News leaked out of this so called kidnapping and a very strong anti-masonic party was soon created, at first only social in it's character, but soon it became political. This feature of the party first appeared at town-meetings in the spring of 1827, where it was resolved that no mason was worthy to receive the votes of freemen. A political party for the exclusion of masons from public offices was soon spread over the State of New York and into several other states, and ran it's course for several years. Cazenovia became one of the strongholds of the anti-mason movement. During this period the Erie canal was being built through Madison County, not many miles north of Cazenovia.  Many people sold their Cazenovia property to move their business and families closer to the canal. This caused the value of the village property to drop, thus causing others to look towards the west for a new home. Ira, Lucy and children Henry & Morris moved from New York to Ohio in 1833.  Shortly after their arrival in May their daughter Nicy E. Clay was born. The next information on Ira's location is found in a list "1835 Males Over the Age of 21 in Delaware County,Ohio". This list shows Ira living in Bennington township, which like Peru, was a part of Delaware County prior to 1848, then becoming Morrow County in 1848. Another link to Bennington township can be found in a grave listing published in the book "Tombstone Inscriptions and Other Records of Delaware County,Ohio" by Esther Weygant Powell  in 1972. On page 313 , in a cemetery referred to as the Vining cemetery, which is located  in Bennington township, on the East side of route 61 about 1 3/4 miles north of the cross road at Fargo the following inscription was copied  on May 27,1948.  The stone reading...  Clay, Friend, son of Ira & Lucy, died Feb.27, 1837. I believe that this was a child who died at birth, or as a small child, due to the location at this cemetery. The name Friend was probably used because most of the population of this community were of the Quaker religion and referred to each other as Friends. Also Friend could have died as an infant before being properly named.  When visiting the cemetery in 1988 the stone was no longer there. It appeared as though they had cleaned up the cemetery and only the readable stones appeared to be reset in concrete. The 1948 description of the cemetery states the condition of the cemetery at that time, had many fallen stones and many unmarked graves. The next record for Ira was found in Delaware County 's Courthouse in deed book Num.19 page 43. This was a deed to inlot Num.32 of the town of Woodbury, Peru Township, Delaware county.  Dated August 5,1836 but not recorded until May 20,1839 the Grantor's being Daniel & Elizabeth Wood and Ira Clay being the Grantee. Daniel Wood was one of the early settlers and the minister of the Alum Creek Friends church near Woodbury, the town being named for him. In the Old Methodist Graveyard in South Woodbury we find among the other Family graves. Clay, Henry D. son of Ira & Lucy : Died April 14 , 1847  :age 22yrs 9months 4days.  This grave appears to be of the same type discribed under Friend Clay's grave in Bennington township. Ira must have died also around 1847 but no stone has been found. A trip to a white house, just north of the Delaware County courthouse, in which old records are being stored, supplied a noteworthy document.  Common Pleas Journal Book 13. 1846-1848. page 308.Oct.20, 1847. On motion it is ordered that George N. Clarke to appointed Adminstrator of Harley W. Clay late of Peru township in this county dec_ on his entering into bond with Marquis Gardner and Timothy Starr his sanctioning in the penalty of one hundred dollar conditioned according to law. Ordered that Joseph Keen, Robert Gardner and David Jones Apraise the personal in lat of said dec. Whereupon court adjourned to half past 8 o'clock tomorrow morning O.H. Power. I don't know if this has anything to do with Ira or Henry D. Clay who both died in 1847 but the fact that they where the only Clays I know of in the township, and the men mentioned are also mentioned in the history of South Woodbury in   A.S. Benedict’s book makes me believe it has some connection. It could also be a slave that was passing thru the area as it is well know for the underground railroad.  Ira's grave has not yet been found. He died around the year 1847 which I have determined by the 1847 tax records that state Ira Clay heirs.  It has been said that there is a "Lost Gardner graveyard" near to the original sight of the Quaker Church which was located on the east side of Alum Creek on what was Rueben Gardner’s land.  In the 1990’s the Morrow County Genealogical makes a record that they found this graveyard but it had no stones. By the 1850 census we find Lucy, Morris & Nicy living next to Nancy Doty’s large family. Within the next couple years Nicy marries John G. Doty and Morris marries Lydia Longwell from Eden (Kilbourne) in Brown Township Delaware County, Ohio and moves there. John entered into the Ohio Volunteer Infantry in the 85th Reg. and later the 88th.  While at Camp Chase he was working as a carpenter during the major changes in August of 1864.  Expanding the prison and other building of the camp. Johns other brothers also served in the war. During this period the ME Church records show many of the wives names since the men were gone.  Lucy lives with John and Nicy Doty, even after the death of Nicy in November of 1872. John and family move to Ashley shortly after Nicy’s death.  Lucy passed away in September of 1879 and is buried with Nicy at South Woodbury. John Doty marries Roxy Powers and has two more daughters before Roxy dies. John lives till June 20 1905 and is buried at South Woodbury. It was probably at that time the newer monument was made that appears there today. All of his children, except Ansyl W. Doty were still alive in 1905.  

A.V. CONKLIN, M.D., a leading citizen of Troy Township, were he owns a valuable farm, 100 acres of land, well-improved and under thorough cultivation, has been prominently identified with the Eclectic School of Medicine, in Ohio, since he received his degree in 1860. He assisted to organize the Ohio State Eclectic Society and was its first vice-president, and served also as the president of that important medical body. Dr. Conklin belongs to an old pioneer family of the State. He was born in Morrow County, Ohio, November 21, 1832, and is a son of Jacob and Orra (Payne) Conklin. The parents of Dr. Conklin were of new England birth, his father coming from Vermont and his mother from Connecticut. Jacob Conklin was a soldier in the War of 1812, and after its close, in 1814, he settled first in Delaware County, Ohio, and later moved to that section which became Morrow County, where he died in 1875. Dr. Conklin was reared in Morrow County and enjoyed educational advantages at Mt. Hesper Seminary, following which he taught school for some years, in this way providing for his own professional education. He taught school for some years, in this way providing for his own professional education. He was graduated form the Eclectic Medical Institute at Cincinnati, in 1860, and practiced subsequently at Waldo and at South Woodbury, in 1875 coming to Delaware County. For many years Dr. Conklin was one of the leading medical practitioners in this section and few men are better known. Public affairs and local good government have claimed his attention, in the light of good citizenship, and he has long been identified with the Republican party, with strong views in favor of temperance. On November 12, 1861, Dr. Conklin was married to Maria Hull, who was born in Marion County, Ohio, and is a daughter of Nathaniel and Nancy (Wyatt) Hull, both of whom died in Marion County. Dr. and Mrs. Conklin have two children: Prof. Edwin G., Ph. D., a member of the faculty of the University of Pennsylvania, filling the chair of Biology; and Eva C., who married Charles Page, residing at Columbus, Ohio. Dr. and Mrs. Conklin are members of the Asbury Methodist Episcopal Church, at Delaware. He is identified with several leading fraternities and has been an Odd fellow since a856 and a Mason for about 37 years. Page 358 

DR. ABRAHAM VIRGIL CONKLIN was born in 1832, in Westfield, Ohio. He is a son of Jacob Conklin, a soldier of 1812, under General McArthur. He received his education in the common schools, and at Mt. Hesper Seminary. After ten years of school teaching, he learned telegraphy, and was employed at Wooster and other places for some years. In 1866 he graduated in the Eclectic Medical Institute at Cincinnati, Ohio. He located near his old home and began the practice at Delaware, Ohio, and afterward moved to Waldo, Marion County. After a short time, he moved to South Woodbury, Morrow County, and in a few years located in the country near Delaware, where he now lives. Years of hard labor have told upon him, and after nearly four score years he has retired from work.

The following is from 20TH CENTURN HISTORY OF DELAWARE COUNTY, OHIO AND REPRESENTATIVE CITIZENS by James R. Lytle, published by Biographical Publishing Company, Chicago, Illinois, in 1908.

H. C. DAVISON, M. D., was born in Morrow County, Ohio, September 25, 1839. He was educated in his native State, and at the age of seventeen began reading medicine at South Woodbury, Ohio, and subsequently took a course at Ohio Medical College. At the age of twenty-one years he came to Blackford County, locating at Trenton. In 1870 he attended the Indiana Medical College, and in 1877 became a resident of Hartford City.    Doctor Davidson was Assistant Surgeon in the Fifty-fourth Indiana Infantry during the war of the Rebellion. He is a member of the Masonic fraternity.

Source: Biographical and Historical Record of Jay and Blackford Counties, Indiana by The Lewis Publishing Company, 1887

John G. Doty

JOHN G. DOTY History of Morrow County  page 894. History of Morrow County page 894. John Doty, grandson of John and Elizabeth(Grove) Gardner and a son of Steven and Nancy (Gardner) Doty, was enrolled June 2, 1862, at South Woodbury, this county, and was mustered into service to take effect the same day as a private of Company C 85th Ohio Infantry Volunteers, to serve  three months. He was appointed sergeant, September 23d, 1862, at Camp Chase, Ohio.  He enlisted the second time, August 5, 1864 at Columbus,Ohio and was mustered into service the same day as a private of Company I, 88th Ohio Infantry Volunteers, to serve one year.  He was mustered out with the company as a private, June 3,1865, at Camp Chase, Ohio, having served an aggregate of one year, one month, and nineteen days.  

 

IsaiahDoty1.jpg (118776 bytes)

 ISAIAH DOTY. History of Morrow County page 894.  Isaiah Doty, brother of the last above named, volunteered March 31, 1864 at Oshkosh, Wisconsin, and was mustered into service April 13, 1864, as a private of Company B, 37th Wisconsin Infantry Volunteers, to serve three years. July 27,1865, he was mustered out with his regiment as a private having served one years, three months, and twenty six days.

GEORGE WASHINGTON DOTY. History of Morrow County page 894-5. George Washington Doty, brother of the last two above named, enlisted June 2, 1862, at Ashley, Ohio, and was mustered into service to take effect the same day as a private of Company C, 85th Ohio Infantry Volunteers, to serve three months. He was appointed sergeant June 11, 1862, and was mustered out with the company as sergeant September 23, 1862. He again enlisted October 16, 1862, at Camp Chase, Ohio, and October 28, 1862, was mustered into service as a corporal of Company C, 88th Ohio Infantry Volunteers, to serve three years. He was appointed sergeant in August 1863, and was mustered out as a sergeant February 4, 1864, at Columbus, Ohio, by reason of appointment as second lieutenant, 27th United States Colored Troops. June 5, 1864 he was promoted to first lieutenant of Company G of that regiment. He was discharged from the service as a first lieutenant on tender of resignation accompanied with a surgeon's certificate of disability, in order from the War Department dated April 20, 1865. His aggregate term of service was two years, nine months and thirteen days.  

JOSEPHUS F. DOTY was born March 16, 1843, at South Woodbury, Morrow Co., Ohio; in the spring of 1857, he went to Ashley to learn the blacksmith trade with S. B. Morehouse ; in the winter of 1858, and until the fall of 1860, he attended school at Mount Hesper, in Morrow Co.; the following winter taught school in Delaware Co., Ind. In the spring of 1861, he returned to Ashley, and upon the first call for troops enlisted as a private May 1, 1861, in Co. C, 26th O. V. L, under Capt. Jesse Meredith, and was made Corporal at the organization of the company, and promoted to Sergeant after the battle of Stone River, where he was slightly wounded. On the 20th of September, 1863, at the battle of Chickamauga, he received two wounds ; one of the balls he still carries in his body; being unable to perform service in the field, during the winter of 1863-64, he was on recruiting service at Todd Barracks, at Columbus, Ohio. In April, 1864, he joined his regiment, when he was made color-bearer, and served as such during the Atlanta campaign. July 25, 1864, he was discharged, having served three years and three months, lacking five days. On the 11th of April, 1865, he again enlisted in the 9th U. S. V., under Maj. Gen. Hancock, and on the d 16th, arrived at Washington, D. C. On the 8th of the following June, he was appointed First Sergeant of Co. B, and on the 10th day of July, Sergeant Major of the regiment, and on the 17th day of same month was commissioned Second Lieutenant in the regiment, and promoted to First Lieutenant the 1st of the following November. The 24th of March, 1866, he was appointed by the Secretary of War Regimental Quartermaster of the same regiment, having served as such from the December previous by special order. The 2d of May, 1866, he was mustered out of the United States service, and settled at Ashley, Ohio. On the 20th day of August, 1865, while in the service, he was married to Miss Millie Baxter.

Also listed in History of Morrow County page 895. “ a younger brother of the four last above”

HARRISON DOTY, runs a planing mill in Ashley; was born at Woodbury, Delaware Co., Ohio, Nov. 6, 1840; when 14 years old, he became an apprentice of H. L. Cross, at Ashley, Ohio, learning the wagon-maker's trade ; in 1858, he purchased an interest in Lincoln Township, Morrow Co., where he remained until August, 1862, when he enlisted in Co. C, 96th O. V. I, and entered the army of the Mississippi; he was in the battles of Chickasaw Bayou, Arkansas Post ; in 1863, he was placed on detached duty, and given charge of a saw-mill to saw lumber for pontoon bridges for crossing the swamps west of Vicksburg ; he was at the battle of Port Gibson, and helped to construct the floating bridge over Bayou Pear, from the dwelling-houses of Port Gibson, and was at the battles of Champion Hills, Black River Bridge ; the charge of Vicksburg from 11 A. M. to sunset ; he also participated in the siege and capture of that place; at the battle of Grand Chateau he was taken prisoner, and was held fifty-three days; he afterward took part in the capture of Forts Gaines and Morgan, at the mouth of Mobile Bay, and unfurled the first regimental colors in front of the last-named fort ; he was with Gen. Banks up Red River ; his brigade fought in the last engagement of infantry at Whistle Station. In July, 1866, he married Miss Phoebe Benedict, who died in December, 1870, leaving one son. Dec. 21, 1871, he married Miss M. E. Carpenter, and in 1873 moved to Ashley, and engaged in the saw and planing mill business. His parents were of the first pioneers of Delaware. Co. He is a member of the Presbyterian Church.   Also listed in History of Morrow County page 895. “a younger brother of John, Isaiah and Washington”  

RILEY DOTY

Obituary: December 21, 1909. Delaware Gazette:

Riley Doty was born in Harmony Twp., Delaware Co., OH (now Morrow Co.) February 13, 1825, died at his home at Leonardburg, Ohio, December 15, 1909, aged 84 yr 10 mo 2 da. He was the son of Stephen W. and Nancy Gardner Doty, and the last surviving member of a family of nine children. His grandfather Stephen W. Doty, put up a grist mill on Alum Creek, near Woodbury, when Riley was 14 yr. of age. Ar the age of 19 he was united in marriage to Mary Ann Gardner. They became parents of five children all of whom had proceeded him to the spirit world. After his marriage he moved to Stantontown, where he operated the Randolph mill for six years. He moved to Woodbury, and while living there he went each season for three years to Iowa to set up and operate saw mills for a Mt. Vernon, OH, firm. He moved to Stiners's Corners in Morrow Co, where he and his brother, Harrison Doty and Henry Stiners operated a mill. While here his wife died. He removed to Leonardsburg and purchased a mill form Isarel Potter, which he operated until about two years ago. January 1, 1867, he was untied in marriage to Noami Elizabeth Brenizer. They became the parents of one son, Josephus Doty, who cared for his father during his long illness. Mr. Doty was actively engaged in the anti-slavery movement. He was a member of the Universalist church for about 60 years. During the civil war Mr. Doty was one of the militia of the state called to Cincinnati to protect the city from the Morgan raiders. Those called out were armed with such guns as they might possess, and were afterwards spoken of as the Squirrel Hunters. The end came December 15th. The funeral services were conducted at the home by Rev. J.R. Gardner, interment in Ashley Cemetery.

(PAC Notes 2008) I have changed the A. to W. in both Stephen Doty's names. Also the defence of Cinncinati was because of Kirby Smith's raid.

 

 

ALVA FROST, b. July 19, 1808, Carmel, Putnam Co. , NY; d. June 30, 1867, Hustiford, Dodge Co. Wisconsin; m. PERMILLA BEARD, 1829, South Woodbury, Ohio; b. January 07, 1809, New York; d. May 06, 1883, Dassel, Meeker Co. MN.

REUBEN B. GARDNER, farmer; P. O. Bennington; grand-son of John Gardner, who was born Aug. 5, 1759, in Scotland, was a soldier under Lord Cornwallis, and surrendered by him Oct. 19, 1781. Settled in the District of Columbia; in 1800 came to Zanesville, Ohio, thence to Delaware in 1812, or what is now Morrow Co., Ohio, purchasing the lands of one Munson, one of the very earliest settlers in Peru. His son, Robert Gardner, who was born Nov. 20, 1792, in the city of Washington, D. C., emigrated with his father to the Buckeye State, and in 1816, July 1st, married Polly Benedict, who was born in the State of New York, June 11, 798. They had the following children: Nelson, born Aug. 9th, 1817; Sarah, Feb. 23, 1819; Reuben, June 18, 1820; Anna, March 23, 1822; Rebecca, Sept. 4, 1823; Phebe J., March 22, 1825; James, born. Nov. 23, 1826, and died same year. Hannah C., born Nov. 15, 1833. December 8th, 1853, the nuptials of Reuben Gardner and Hannah O. Wilson were celebrated by the Rev. Win. King. Hannah's birthday occurred Sept. 3, 1831; she was therefore over 10 years his junior. Their family names are-Alice Eugenia, born Aug. 3 1854, and died Oct. 24. 1878: Albert Nelson, born Feb. 4, 1859; Eva Bell, May 10, 1863; Nevada Alaska, Oct. 4, 1870. Cora Alaska, his grand-child, and whose home is with her grand-father Reuben, was born May 8, 1875. On the 18th day of Feb., 1866, Eva Bell died, making two deaths, that have occurred in Reuben's family. By occupation Reuben Gardner is a farmer, but largely engaged in stock-raising, the buying and selling of stock, etc. He has held the office of Township Trustee for 12 years, Trustee of Church and Parsonage, School Director for 20 years, Treasurer of the Odd Fellows Society for 3 years, with numerous other trusts. In religious opinions he is of the Methodist Episcopal caste. A member of that church. In his agricultural purposes, sheep husbandry forms his strongest bias, and that of cattle his next, and one thing must always be observable with regard to him, and that is his remarkable power to remember names and dates.  

WASHINGTON GARDNER, farmer; P. O., Cardington; was born in Muskingum Co., O., Nov. 2, 1814; son of John and Elizabeth (Groves) Gardner. His father was born near Paisley, in Scotland, and came to America during the Revolutionary War; he was a soldier in that war. He was born in 1750, and our subject's mother was born in Pennsylvania, in 1769, and her parents were born in Holland. Mr. Gardner is the youngest of a family of twelve children; there are only four of the family now living. His parents came to Morrow Co., O., in a very early day; they settled in Peru Tp., there being only three or four families in the township at the time they came. His father died in Feb., 1836; and his mother in 1847. He was raised on a farm, and resided with his parents until their deaths; he received a common school education; was married in 1847 to Mary Wiseman, whose parents came to Morrow Co. from Crawford Co., in about 1843; they were natives of Pennsylvania. She was born March 6, 1828; her father was born in about 1783, and mother in 1795. From this union there were nine children, five being dead, those living are Zachary, Winfield S., Maggie A., Albert, John F., Lola M., Oscar M., Mary A., Nellie R. Mr. Gardner began business for himself entirely upon his own resources, and all that he has was made by himself. He served eleven months in the late war, enlisted July 25, 1861, in the 26th 0. V. I., Co. G; was discharged June 16, 1862. He and his wife are members of the U. B. Church.

 

SWHarknessp14.jpg (1080016 bytes)

JESSE S. HARKNESS, teacher, Bennington was born in Cheshire Co., N. H.. July 27, 1813, and Sept. 21, 1841, married Cynthia H. Tabor, of Bedford, Canada East, who on the 14th day of Jan., 1818, was born in Addison Co., Vermont. In the fall of 1842 they arrived in that part of Marion Co., now included in Morrow, and for six ensuing months taught school to-ether in the house of Samuel Peasley. In the spring of 1842 moved to Aden Benedict's house, teaching meanwhile in the old brick church belonging to the Society of Friends, which stood near by. In 1844' they began the erection of the present college building, which was not completed and occupied until in 1845, when it was dedicated under the name of Hespermount Seminary. The school first opened in connection with the district school, and under the most favorable auspices, the scholars from the district attending, and the funds from the state being applied therefor, and one week was the longest vacation which occurred for twenty years, making an average of four terms per annum. In consequence of ill health, Mr. Harkness was forced to discontinue the school for five years, since which but three terms per annum have been held. For many years the average attendance was from 40 to 75 scholars, and the real maximum was an attendance of 109 scholars. It has been of inestimable value to the citizens in the immediate vicinity and surrounding country. The school will be treated in its appropriate place in the history of the township. It has been a source of profit to the originators. Being from 'New Hampshire, Mr. Harkness of course would have his marked New England proclivities, and very naturally turned his attention to the importation of the so-called Vermont fine sheep, and their introduction into Morrow Co., and to him is mainly due much of the improvement see n in the country in sheep husbandry. He was the first to introduce steam as a motor into Peru Tp., and which he for three years employed in the manufacture of spokes and hubs, for wagons and carriages. He also completed wagons and carriages for sale Jesse S. Harkness has never had any children of his own, yet with true magnanimity, he has reared and educated many poor and indigent children, and in many cases has admitted such to the privileges of the seminary, free. The children thus cared for embrace all ages, from twenty months to thirteen years of age. And thus the advantages of home, parents, Christian training and education, have inured to these unfortunates through this individual instrumentality. He is a member of the Quaker Society, and a man of advanced ideas, but in educational matters, or matters of finance and sound political economy, he is somewhat radical. Hespermount Seminary lies about one mile south of the village of South Woodburg, and the Ashley and Marengo Road.

 

James R. Hubbell

HUBBELL, JAMES RANDOLPH, a Representative from Ohio; born in Lincoln Township, Delaware County, Ohio, July 13, 1824; attended the common schools; taught school at Woodbury, Ohio; studied law; was admitted to the bar in 1845 and commenced practice at London, Ohio; moved to Delaware, Ohio, and continued the practice of law; member of the State house of representatives in 1849, 1858, 1859, 1862, and 1863 and served as speaker in 1863; elected as a Republican to the Thirty-ninth Congress (March 4, 1865-March 3, 1867); appointed by President Johnson as Minister to Portugal, but his nomination was not confirmed; resumed the practice of law; served in the State senate in 1869; resigned for the purpose of accepting the Democratic nomination for Congress; unsuccessful Democratic candidate for election in 1870 to the Forty-second Congress; died at the home of his son in Bellville, Ohio, on November 26, 1890; interment in Oak Grove Cemetery, Delaware, Ohio.

OBIT: Dec.3,1890 Delaware Gazzette :states he had 4 sons and 3 daughters Hon. James R. Hubbell part of article. On Wednesday evening at six o'clock, November 26, A.D., 1890, at the residence of his son, R.J. Hubbell, at Bellville, Richland county, Ohio, departed this life one of Delaware county's best known citizens, the Hon. James R. Hubbell, whose remains were brought to our city to be interred in Oak Grove Cemetery, beside his wife, Mary, and two sons, Shadrach and Thomas C., whose sad demise and irreparable loss to him some twenty or more years ago had much to do in shaping the destinies of a character susceptible to the emotions and mutatations of a kindly and generous nature. James Randolph Hubbell was born in Lincoln township, then in Delaware county, on the 13th day of July, in 1824. His father Shadrach Hubbell, was a native of the state of New York, and his mother, Rebecca Randolph Hubbell, a native of Green county, state of Pennsylvania. They were married in the year 1821 and had eight children, all of whom are deseased except Hiram Hubbell, living in Ross county, Ohio and Mrs. Susan E. Hipple, living in this city. Shadrach Hubbell was a farmer, and his son, James R., had the usual experience and opportunities of a boy of the early settlers. When a lad of but 12 years of age he was engaged in carrying the United States mail on horse-back from Woodbury to Delaware on the roads that were then almost impassable. He obtained all the advantages of a common school education, and himself became a teacher at Woodbury when about 17 years of age. Among his teachers were men who afterward became prominent citizens, and of whom he often spoke in the highest terms of praise. The late Auditor of Delaware County, Charles Neil, now deseased, was one who taught a select school at "Cherry Grove", near Eden, whose thorough knowledge of the common branches and whose mathematical genius left its impress upon the mind of his student. Mr. Hubbell read law with Hon. Thomas W. Powell, of Delaware, and was admitted to the Bar at London, Ohio, June 5, 1845, afterward established an office in Delaware, and had a successful and lucrative practice for many years, and accumulated a handsome fortune, at one time owning a farm of three hundred acres of the best land in Brown township, where himself and family often spent the summer months. He married Mary, one of the daughters of Ralph Longwell, of Brown township, a farmer and one of the first settlers their. And the farmer's son and the farmer's daughter never quite forgot their early love of home in the country, and hence their oft repeated moves from the city to summer on the farm, where the family all seemed to enjoy themselves to the fullest extent, and especially Mr. Hubbell, who loved the surroundings that furnished an opportunity for those quiet reveries in which he loved to indulge and are beautifully expressed in some lines of his favorite and often repeated poem:

THE MANSFIELD HERALD: 04 December 1890, Vol. 41, No. 3. The funeral of James R. Hubbell, who died at Bellville Wednesday night, took place Friday. Interment was had at Delaware. Submitted by Amy

 

F. M. JAMES, farmer; P. O., Bennington; was born in Virginia, Feb. 6, 1823; son of David and Charlotte James; the father was a native of Virginia, and the mother of Maryland; they came to Morrow Co. in 1836, where they resided until their death-the father May 24, 1858, and the mother Sept. 19, 1869. Mr. James' youth was spent at home, and at the age of 19 he went to learn the wagon-makers' trade-a business he followed for about ten years, after which he purchased a farm in Lincoln Tp., and has been following farming and stock-growing since. He was married about 1844, to Miss Anna Barnard, whose parents were natives of Vermont, and came to Ohio about 1836, and are both living. From their marriage they have three children-Elizabeth, George B. and Edmund. Mr. James owns a farm of 100 acres, most of which he cleared and improved; he has resided in Lincoln Tp., about thirty-one years; previous to coming here he lived in Peru Tp. twelve years, making 43 years in the county; being but a wilderness at the time of settlement, they have seen it improved to its present civilized condition. Mrs. James is a daughter of Edmund and Laura Barnard; she is the eldest of a family of seven children. Mr. and Mrs. James are members of the M. E. Church.

SAMUEL LEVERING, farmer; P. O. Ashley; the grandfather of Samuel Levering was Griffith Levering, a ship carpenter in Philadelphia; his grandmother was Hannah Griscom. His son, Thomas Levering, was born in Philadelphia in 1781, and Thomas' wife, Rachel Ann Schofield, was born in North Carolina, in 1798; their marriage occurred in December, 1814, after which they resided in Washington City, D. C., engaged in the grocery business. In 1832 Thomas came to Ohio, and located on lands purchased from Jacob Van Deventer (a still earlier pioneer), near the site of West Liberty. The same year Thomas purchased five quarter sections, whose titles bore the signature of General Andrew Jackson. In 1839 he again went east, locating in Cecil Co., Md., until 1847, when he again came to Ohio. Thomas Levering had two sons, Griffith and Samuel. Griffith born Aug. 10, 1818; Samuel born Sept. 22, 1828, in the City of Brotherly Love. Samuel, the subject of this sketch, settled on what was known as the Joseph Keane farm, in 1850, and the next year made additional purchases. On the 20th of Nov., 1852, he married Miss Ada R. Hathaway, born Jan. 13, 1830, near Milan, Erie Co., Ohio. Samuel has the following children-Rachel Ella, Thomas Henry, a teacher in the Industrial Boarding School, Wyandotte Mission, Indian Territory; Mary Alice, Clara Maria, Laura Letitia, Susanna Matilda, Jennie Eva, Fanny Esther, Ralph Griffith and George Canby. Rachel Ella is the Principal in Alum Creek Academy. In 1856 Samuel erected the stately family mansion he now occupies, he himself being a carpenter by trade. He is an extensive farmer and stock breeder, especially of fine Durham cattle and fine wooled sheep, the latter of which he handles in large quantities. He has paid unusual attention to family education, several members of his family being graduates. He also, in connection with Dr. Townsend, has erected and put into successful operation Alum Creek Academy, which, however, will be treated of in the history of the township at large. He has bestowed great care and expense in beautifying his grounds and surroundings, rendering Sunny Slope, (the name of his home) one of the most attractive in the country. He is a devoted member of the Society of Friends, a church organization which has existed in his locality from the earliest settlement.

 

JOHN McCONICA, farmer; P. O., Marengo; was born Feb. 4, 1824. His father, James, was born about 1795, in Ireland, and when young engaged in weaving, and in 1811 came to New York, and thence to Trumbull Co., Ohio, and soon afterward enlisted in the war of 1812, in which he remained until the close, and then came to Delaware Co., Ohio, where he was engaged by the month; he was married in 1820, to Hannah, daughter of Ephraim and Elizabeth (Collins) Hubbell; she was born in 1804. They settled on the farm now owned by Jacob Long, of this township, and here the mother of our subject died in 1836; she was the mother of seven children - Benjamin, deceased; John, Elizabeth, Nancy, Alfred, Angeline and Hannah. The father then put the children out, among relatives, and repaired to Illinois, and lived a single and lonely life until 1870, when he died. Himself and wife were active members of the Methodist Church. John- learned tailoring and continued at the same for some time, and then clerked for awhile for G. N. Clark, at South Woodbury. He then merchandised at Galion for some time, under the firm name of Hubbell & McConica. He was married in 1851 to Refilla, a daughter of Thomas and Rebecca Madden; she was born Feb. 27, 1830. They settled in Lincoln Tp., and during the same year he bought 84 acres of land of J. Wiseman; he has also 100 acres in Harmony Tp., upon which he resides. He had six children, two of whom are dead. The living are-Wilbert L., married Luella Gardner; Thomas H., Charles C.; Minnie M. married William Fulton. He has served a full share of township offices; is a member of Mt. Gilead Lodge, F. and A. M. Mr. McConica is the architect of his own fortune. He bought and traded stock for many years, in which he was successful, as all are who attend strictly to business. His brother Alfred studied medicine with Dr. I. H. Pennock, and attended the Starling Medical College at Columbus, Ohio.

E. B. MOSHER, M. D., physician and surgeon, Sunbury ; is a son of David and Phoebe (Buck) Mosher. His father was born in NewYork about 1811, and came to Ohio when young; was a farmer and stockraiser. His mother was a daughter of Edward Buck, of New York, who came to Morrow Co., Ohio, when young, where she was born about 1813. They had nine children ; but six survive. Theodore was also a physician, and was killed by lightning while on the way home from visiting a patient. His father was in the buggy, by his side, when his son and the horse were both killed almost instantly. Mr. Mosher was born June 30, 1837, in Morrow Co.; at the age of 2, his parents moved to Knox Co., Ill.. and was there five years ; they then returned to Morrow Co., and engaged in farming; when 17, he attended school at Mt. Hesper, Ohio; after ward attended the Wesleyan University at Delaware one year; he then taught one term of school, near Ashley; in 1853, he began reading medicine with Dr. I. H. Pennock, of South Woodbury, Ohio, and continued three years ; in 1856, he attended one term of lectures at the Starling Medical College at Columbus; then practiced medicine at Ashley until the war broke out. In August, 1861, he enlisted in the 15th O. V. I., as hospital steward ; the first eighteen months he was with the regiment, after which he engaged on the hospital train for four months ; he then went before the Medical Board of Surgeons and was commissioned as Surgeon, and assigned to the 172d O. V. I., where he remained until his time expired ; he then returned to Ohio, and began practicing at Olive Green, until 1870, when he attended lectures at Louisville, Ky., where he graduated in 1871, returning then to Olive Green; in 1873, he settled in Sunbury, where he has a lucrative practice. Was married in September, 1857, to Martha Liggett, a daughter of Alexander and Sarah Liggett, of Ohio ; she was born in 1839 ; they have four children-Cora B., married G. K. Sharp; Myrtle L., Minnie I., Gracie M.    

 

PennockLetter.jpg (142812 bytes)  Isaac H. Pennock Letter of recommendation written for Albert E. Westbrook. 1862

ISAAC H. PENNOCK, banker; Cardington; was born in Columbiana Co., O., Aug. 16, 1825 ; his parents, William and Abigail (Welch) Pennock, were natives of Pennsylvania, the mother coming from the "Quaker City, " and the father from Chester Co. They were of English descent, and held with their ancestors to the religious tenets of the followers of Win. Penn. The offspring of William and Abigail Pennock were one son-Isaac H., and five daughters, all of whom are now living, as is the mother, at an advanced age, attesting to the vigor and vitality of the o inal stock. The Pennocks came to Ohio while it was yet a part of the great Northwest Territory. John Pennock, the grandfather, built the first mill in that portion of the State now known as Columbiana Co. William Pennock, the father, was also a mill-wright and a successful business man. he departed this life in 1847. Isaac H. Pennock spent his early years in the schools of his native village, and at the age of fifteen years began the study of medicine at Marlborough, in Stark Co., O. He was a diligent and untiring student, and at the early age of nineteen graduated at the Ohio Medical College of Cincinnati. He came to Morrow Co. in 1843, and began the practice of medicine ; he remained at Woodbury twenty years, and while located there attended lectures at some of the best medical colleges in the United States. In the fall of 1859 he was united in marriage with Carrie A., youngest daughter of Maj. Samuel and Annie (Northrop) Clark, of Boardman, Mahoning Co., O. Maj. Clark emigrated from New Milford, Litchfield Co., Ct., and settled in Boardman in 1810, at which time nearly the whole of the Western Reserve was a wilderness. In 1863 Dr. Pennock removed to Cardington, where he continued actively in the practice of medicine until 1875, since which time he has devoted the most of his time to banking and agriculture; as a physician he was regarded as among the first in this section of the State, always a careful and close student of Pathology, as he found it in his practice; he became a leader in the use of new and rational remedies, and with uniform success. Shortly after locating in Cardington, he in connection with W. H. Marvin, Gen. John Beatty and others, organized under the National Banking law, the "First National Bank " of Cardington, and has been the president an the largest stock holder, of the bank since its organization; he is also President of the Citizens' National Bank of Galion, O., and a stockholder and Director in the Morrow Co. National Bank of Mt. Gilead, and the Citizens' Savings Bank of Columbus. With sound judgment conducting his large business interests, he yet finds time to speak encouragement to the young and struggling members of the profession with whom he started in the world. With social qualities of a high order, he is an earnest, temperance advocate, and those who have heard him in his deliberate way sum up the evidence in the case against the great social evil, will admit that he practices temperance by precept as well as by example. His wife is an amiable lady, accomplished and pleasing. In Dr. Pennock's family are two children-William C. and Mary A.; the son is now attending Kenyon College, near Mt. Vernon, O., and the daughter a seminary for young ladies at Poughkeepsie, New York.

JOSEPH RUSSELL, farmer; P. O., Cardington; was born in Miami Co., O., Dec. 14, 1823. His father was a native of South and his mother of North Carolina. The father went to Miami Co. in about 1808, where he was married to Tamar Mendenhall, whose parents came to the same county in an early day. From this marriage there were ten children, three of whom are dead; Joseph is next to the oldest of the family. He resided with his parents until of age, at, which time he began business for himself. He has been married twice; his first marriage was Nov. 13, 1851, to Ann Bunker, whose parents were old residents of Morrow Co.; she was born May 25, 1828; from this union there is one son-William H., born June 26, 1853; she died Dec. 31, 1855. Mr. Russell lived a widower until Feb. 12, 1857, when he was again married. His second wife was Priscilla A. Buck; the history of her parents will be seen in this work; she was born July 25, 1827. Mr. Russell has always followed farming and stock raising; he owns about 32 acres of well improved land, and is in good, comfortable circumstances. His father died Oct. 18, 1873, and his mother in December of the same year.

SOLOMON WESTBROOK., Solomon Westbrook, son of John Westbrook, who settled in Canandaigua County, New York. The Westbrook family originally came from Germany, two brothers, John and Leonard, coming to this country at an early date."Solomon Westbrook, the doctor's father, was born in 1798 in Canandaigua County, New York and in 1816 moved to Johnstown, Licking County, Ohio. He married Mrs. Mathena Crawford, nee Edmunds, it being the second marriage for both. He had one son by his first marriage , and she had six children by her first marriage to William Crawford. She was the daughter of Samuel Edmunds, who also came from Canandaigua County, New York to Johnstown , Ohio.Of the children of several unions, but one aside from Dr.(AE) Westbrook is living- the latter's full sister Jane, who is the widow of Robert Gardner, and lives one mile north of South Woodbury.Solomon Westbrook followed farming until after his marriage, at Johnstown, and then conducted a hotel until 1836. He then went on horseback to New Orleans, where he practiced medicine for one year, after which he returned to his home, then shortly afterward journeyed in the same manner to Canada and back. In 1849 he went to Missouri, and from St. Joseph crossed the plains to San Francisco with a company from Delaware , Ohio . He drove three yoke of oxen and walked every step of the way. Many were the hardships endured by the party, Dr. Mann of Delaware, died of scurvy after his arrival. Mr. Westbrook remained two years in the West, working in the gold mines, and upon his return to Ohio had $500 in gold, being no richer and no poorer than when he left."

 

A. E. WESTBROOK, physician and surgeon, Ashley ; was born in South Woodbury, Morrow Co., Ohio, Dec. 17, 1840 ; he was the son of Solomon and Mathena Westbrook, who came to Ohio in 1816 ; he received his early education at Mt. Hesper Seminary ;afterward attended the Ohio Wesleyan University at Delaware, Ohio; he read medicine with Dr. I. H. Pennock, of Morrow Co., and completed the medical course at the Cincinnati College of Medicine and Surgery, February, 1863 ; he began practicing medicine at Ashley in 1865. In August, 1863, he entered the 106th O. V. I., as Surgeon, in which position he served until 1865 ; during the war, he was oil detached duty at Gallatin, Tenn ; he had charge of the Post Hospital, and was Medical Director on the staff of Brig. Gen. E. A. Payne, at Gallatin, Tenn.; he had charge of Forts Negly, Huston, and Morton, at Nashville, and was on duty at the hospital in Stevenson, Ala.; for a time was Surgeon in the 68th N. Y. V. I. He is a member of the American Medical Association, the Ohio State Medical Society, and the Delaware County Medical Association, of which he was Vice President in 1876, and was elected President in 1878. Dr. W. has always taken a great interest in the public schools of his town, which, through his efforts mainly, was changed from a district to a union of graded school, in 1879 ; he is at present a member of the School Board. He was married, in 1866, to Amanda E., daughter of Judge Cunard, of Mt. Gilead, Ohio, and has three children Edward Cunard, Blanche Alberta and Grace Sumner.

LAFAYETTE WESTBROOK, farmer; P. O., Ashley; son of Solomon and Marthena (Crawford) Westbrook. The former was born in the State of New York Feb. 3, 1798, and died June 11, 1872. His wife was born in the Empire State, March 20,1792, and died Jan. 1, 1879. In Johnstown, Licking Co., O., April 17,1822, they were married. He became a citizen of Peru Tp. in 1840. His family was Mary Ann, Anne, Lafayette, William, Jane, and Dr. Albert E. Westbrook, now of Ashley. Lafayette Westbrook was born July 28, 1829, in Johnstown, Licking Co., Ohio; he moved to Morrow Co. in 1840; in 1849, he married Miss Harriet Hubbell, a sister of the Hon. J. R. Hubbell, who was born Oct. 29, 1829, and who met an untimely death May 1, 1868. His children are-Rosedell, born Oct. 24, 1849, now dead; Kate, born Dec. 17, 1851; Orville, March 10, 1854; Mary R., July 14, 1857; Flora E., March 3, 1860; Shadrach, Nov. 22, 1862, and Pruda, Dec. 17, 1867. Nov. the 26th, 1868, Lafayette was again married to Phebe Randolph, born Oct. 2, 1839, the daughter of Nathan and Sarah Ann Randolph. From this union, he has one child, Minnie E., born June 27, 1870. The vicissitudes of his life have been varied; at 14 years of age, he was apprenticed to a tailor and served 3 years; and then learned the wagon-making business. He has played the role of hotel keeper, also, and at last settled down as a farmer, delighting in good horses and fine-wooled sheep, occupying one of the oldest establishments in the township, the Randolph Farm. With him life has had many fitful changes, but withal he has made it a success.  

 

SWWilliamWestbrook.JPG (64081 bytes) Grave located at South Woodbury ME Cemetery

WILLIAM WESTBROOK, farmer; P. O., Bennington; born June 12, 1831, in Bloomfield Tp., Knox Co., Ohio; is one of those farmers and stock-dealers whose energy and industry have placed him in easy and comfortable circumstances. The 4th day of July, 1852, he married Miss Emeline Wiseman, who was born Oct. 8, 1833. The children of this marriage are--Vanda, born July 6, 1854; Frank, Dec. 23, 1855; Albert, Jan. 13, 1858; William H., Jan. 28, 1860; James C., born Jan. 17, 1862, and died March 13, 1868; Laura D., born Sept. 27, 1865, the same year in which James C. died. Mrs. Emeline Westbrook died July 27, 1868. Dec. 19, 1873, William Westbrook married Rosa Besse for his second wife, and 1874 their first child, Berton Westbrook, was born. He is earnestly devoted to stock-raising, more especially horses and sheep; William Westbrook has made marked improvement in stock, more especially sheep, and like his brother Lafayette, though some may outrival him in numbers, few will excel him in quality. It is now twenty-four years since Mr. Westbrook came to the farm where he now resides. He having in the meantime purchased, and now owns the farm on which that remarkable prodigy, the double babes were born, whose history, though brief, was world-wide.

CYNTHIA WEBBER PHILBROOK -WOOD. DAVID PORTER PHILBROOK  was born on 22 Jul 1835 in St. Albans, Licking, Ohio.  He died on 26 Nov 1865 in Marseilles Twp., Wyandot Co., Ohio. He was buried in Tymotchee Cemetery, Wyandot County, Ohio. David Porter PHILBROOK and Cynthia WEBBER were married on 2 Oct 1862 in Ashley, Delaware, Ohio. They resided at Marseilles, OH. Cynthia WEBBER (daughter of Lyman John WEBBER and Mary Ann GOODNOW) was born on 8 Jul 1840 in Whittingham, Windham Co., Vermont. She died on 27 Jul 1908 in South Woodbury, Morrow, Ohio. She was buried in South Woodbury Cemetery, South Woodbury, Morrow, Ohio. David Porter PHILBROOK and Cynthia WEBBER had the following children:

1. Carrie May PHILBROOK was born on 7 Sep 1863 in Jersey, Licking, Ohio. She died on 26 Apr 1880 in Peru, Morrow, Ohio.

2.   William Christopher Philbrook. was born in 1865 in Delaware County, Ohio. He died on 21 Aug 1952 in Cardington, Morrow, Ohio. William Christopher PHILBROOK and Edith NICHOLS were married. Edith NICHOLS(daughter of Jacob NICHOLS and Peace MOSHER) was born on 2 Nov 1866 in Lincoln Twp., Morrow County, Ohio. She died on 22 Aug 1947 in Cardington, Morrow, Ohio